Turnaround
Kestrel Airlines, a mid-sized US airline, must return to operating breakeven within 12 months or face a forced sale.
← Back to the case library · How profitability cases run
Kestrel Airlines is a mid-sized US carrier headquartered in Minneapolis-Saint Paul (MSP). It operates a point-to-point network of 82 domestic cities with a fleet of 140 aircraft (130 mainline 172-seat narrowbodies and 10 regional jets). In FY2024, Kestrel flew 15.8 million passengers over 22.5 billion available seat miles (ASMs) and generated $2.84 billion in revenue.
Kestrel has now posted operating losses for three consecutive years. FY2024 produced an operating loss of $160 million on revenue of $2,843 million, an operating margin of roughly minus 5.6%. The board has issued an ultimatum: management must return the airline to operating breakeven within 12 months, or the board will pursue a sale. There is interest from private equity and from a foreign flag carrier, but at distressed multiples of roughly 3x forward EBITDA, which the board sees as a last resort.
Management's narrative is consistent and loud: fuel is the single largest cost line at almost 30% of revenue and is "killing us"; corporate travel has structurally declined since the pandemic; and low-cost carriers keep undercutting leisure fares. The CFO points out, almost as an aside, that Kestrel's revenue per available seat mile (RASM) is actually above the low-cost benchmark, which is why no one has questioned revenue. Two previous cost programs failed, with the network team defending "competitive presence" on every route proposed for exit and the union locals pointing out that the pilots' and flight attendants' collective agreements expire in 14 months, just after the board's 12-month deadline.
You have been asked to advise the board. The key decision is whether a credible, quantified turnaround plan exists that returns Kestrel to operating breakeven within 12 months, and if so, what that plan should contain. If not, the board should sell.
Structuring Judgement Numeracy Creativity Expertise SynthesisCase Ace opens the case, poses the questions one at a time, reveals exhibits at the right moments and scores you against the model answer. Included in the MBB bundle — £40 for everything.
or get access to everything →